Friday, 15 April 2016

Is culture an easy get out?

To the Management Accounting Research Group yesterday where it was a pleasure to catch up with many academic colleagues and friends. The break out session was a useful idea and allowed members of the large audience a chance to say something.

Although the day was supposed to be about business models, it turned out that people were more interested in talking about culture. As 'Whatdoesaprofessordoallday' has observed, after a disaster culture is often blamed. Is this a way of not blaming individuals? Is culture a form of control to stop people acting in their short run interests?

Monday, 28 November 2011

Small Companies

BIS has a discussion paper on small companies. Although the discussion period has formally closed I understand they are still accepting comments.

Tuesday, 12 April 2011

House of Lords Report

All power to the House of Lords committee for taking the auditors to task. Predictably they reacted defensively but we shall see if any meaningful reforms result.

Thursday, 28 October 2010

Did Financial Reporting contribute to the Global Financial Crisis

People sometimes ask me whether poor financial reporting, in particular the use of fair value measurement contributed to the Global Financial Crisis.

A recent article by Laux and Leuz in Accounting Organisations and Society reviews research on the question. It is linked from here.

The House of Lords Economic Affairs Select Committee is looking into the Audit Market. The meeting televised here considers the question of the financial crisis

http://www.parliamentlive.tv/Main/Player.aspx?meetingId=6801

Ex-chancellor Nigel Lawson describes the auditors as the dogs that didn't bark. Tim Bush provides a number deficiencies of IFRS, including the loss of 'prudence'.

IAS Plus has a timeline on regulation which includes summaries of a number of financial reporting issues

http://www.iasplus.com/crunch/creditcrunch.htm#0911casey

Accountancy Age has numerous articles touching on the topic. A list of them can be found here

How to find the conceptual framework

Further to my previous post, I find that one can obtain free access to the new chapters 1 and 3 of the conceptual framework from the FASB website, where it is lurking disguised as SFAC 8.

Tuesday, 28 September 2010

The stately dance continues

The IASB and FASB have today published the definitive (for the moment) chapters of their joint conceptual framework for financial reporting. The project, which is supposed to lead to 'internally consistent' standards is already so riddled with contradictions that it has little credibility. However, the long extended search for a framework allows the standard setters to defer awkward questions almost indefinitely.

The latest twist [1] is the assertion that the purpose of financial statements is to

'To provide financial information about the reporting entity that is useful to existing and potential investors, lenders and other creditors in making decisions about providing resources to the entity.'

The irony of this is that most equity investors never provide any financial resources to an entity. They buy and sell second-hand shares. When new resources are supplied to an entity, more information, by way of prospectuses and so on, is created that supplements financial statements.


[1] Well I assume the final document includes this phrase. At the time of writing I'm relying on a previous document as I don't have access to the actual document; it is not freely available - one has to pay for a subscription to get it.

Thursday, 18 March 2010

A new financial statement? Or an old one?

David Tweedie has apparently confirmed that the IASB is considering including a 'regulators'' page in financial statements so that people concerned with financial institutions can be given the information they need to ensure market stability. It's quite likely that this will include something that looks very like a historical cost balance sheet, and so, rather being something new, this might signal a return to something old.

This could be a fascinating accounting experiment and would give standard setters an opportunity to find out what information is actually demanded, has impact and has value relevance. I foresee the growth of a minor industry in researching the relative importance of regulatory and 'decision useful' information.

More on Lehman's

Our growth in understanding what went on at Lehman's proceeds apace. Despite the criticism of financial transactions that occurred in London, it seems the accounting that is at issue occurred in the USA. It's said that because the Repo transactions involved exchanging assets worth more than $105 for every $100 of cash received SFAS 140 permitted them to be treated as sales because Lehman's wouldn't have had enough cash to buy them back again.

Wednesday, 17 March 2010

Layers of the onion

The Lehman collapse has been blamed as the crucial event in the credit crunch but now it is revealed that aggressive accounting had been hiding problems for some time. The device that it is alleged was used to manipulate the financial statements was accounting for repo (repurchase) transactions.

In a repo an asset (a block of loans, say) is exchanged for cash, and the exchange reversed some time later. In substance this is usually a short term loan with the asset being used as collateral.

It's alleged that Lehman's were accounting for these as sales so that the asset disappeared off the balance sheet and the cash was used to reduce net borrowing. The effect is to reduce the bank's reserve ratio to within acceptable limits.

How was Lehman able to count these transactions as sales rather than loans? How was it able to exploit the provisions of the relevant US accounting standard, SFAS 140? It is likely that Lehaman's did so by a piece of cheeky financial engineering whereby the transaction took three stages, with the asset going back and forth to the counter-party three, and ultimately, four times. The title link shows how this is done.

What we don't yet know, is why this had to be done in London, the role of fair value, whether the financial reporting in the UK reflected the same things as the American accounting, and whether the accounting was routed through off-shore vehicles.

This one will run and run.

Wednesday, 27 January 2010

Success in Doctoral Studies

At a recent research forum the following success index for PhD studies was proposed:

PhD Success Formula

S= (HW + 3M + NR/4)xC/A
___________________
(1 + FM + FB/10 + S)

Where: HW= Hours worked on thesis

M = meetings with supervisor

NR = number of references

C= Average number of cups of tea/coffee per day +1

A=Average units of alcohol per day + 1

FM = ln(Number of family members)

FB= Number of Facebook friends

S= Number of Sports teams supported + 4 x Number of sports played regularly.

While this is clearly an early attempt at a descriptive index related to probability of success it indicates the need for further research to improve the functional form and parameterisation. One commentator has already suggested that comsumption of illegal drugs should be added into the measurement of A, for example.

Wednesday, 2 December 2009

Mintzberg on Bonuses

In an article in the Wall Street Journal (click on title link), management guru, Henry Mintzberg, questions whether directors' bonuses are necessary at all. A very timely question, in my opinion. There is little evidence that bonuses create long term value or that managerial talent is in very scarce supply. My personal preference would be to pay CEOs a fixed multiple of the average salary in the organisation. At least it would stop directors pay increasing faster than the average and it would be an incentive for companies to give a better deal to their low paid workers.

Monday, 30 November 2009

Politicisation of Accounting Standards

The article in the title reports the Association of British Insurers bemoaning the EU's refusal to endorse IFRS 9 'Financial Instruments'. ABI spokesperson, Paul Vipond, regrets the 'politicisation' of accounting standards.

Is politicisation such a bad thing? Standard setters are in business making rules about how companies keep score. These rules can have real economic effects that make some people better off and some people worse off. For example, many people hold the pensions standards partly to blame for the demise of final salary pension schemes. Now, this kind of decision about wealth transfers is quite rightly in the political domain - our elected representatives should be the people making these decisions, not a private and largely self perpetuating organisation, such as the IASB.

The IASB likes to pretend that its work is purely technical and that it is devoted to improving the way that financial statements 'tell things as they are' so that decision makers are more fully informed. By denying that accounting standards involve choices that affect individuals and companies, the IASB attempts to avert criticism about its legitimacy.

If IASB were doing its job properly it would be looking at the likely economic and social impact of its standards.

Tuesday, 24 November 2009

Bob Monks lecture

My thanks to the corporate governance blog for drawing my attention to this lecture by Governance Guru Bob Monks on the past, present and future of governance. There is an accompanying paper at:

http://www.ragm.com/BlogPosts/HLSClass111009.pdf

Monday, 16 November 2009

A clash of philosophies?

The EU has deferred accepting the IASB's new standard on financial instruments (IFRS 9). According an article in the FT (see title link) this is because some EU countries (principally Germany, France and Italy) see a role for financial reporting in maintaining stability of financial systems, whereas the IASB doesn't.

This seems to be a case of the IASB being misled by its own propaganda. Although the constitution of the IASB gives it a role in wider economic matters, it steadfastly refuses to admit that its narrow focus on the presumed interests of capital providers may not provide those benefits.

In a recent lecture at the Institute of Chartered Accountants, Professor Mike Power suggested that, in relation to 'fair value', people could divided into fundamentalists and pragmatists. The fundamentalists couldn't see any alternative to fair value whereas the pragmatists' main interest was in whether accounting standards worked or not. His main point was that because of different philosophical standpoints the two groups of people couldn't understand each other's views.

In particular the 'fundamentalists' (I think he may have included the IASB staffers in this category) can't understand the objections other people have to their standards.

A useful website

The title link is to the World Gap Info website that provides access to news, commentary and the full text of International Standards without the need to register and login at www.iasb.org.uk.

Thursday, 12 November 2009

New financial instruments standard

The IASB has just published a new standard as part of its project to update IAS 39 on the measurement of financial instruments. Accountancy Age (see title link) refers to this as a 'fair value' standard which is confusing as there is another ongoing project to redefine what is meant by 'fair value'. The IASB's press release about the new financial instrument standard is here. At first sight this looks like a considerable reversal of the trend towards fair value for everything but the Europeans are still suspicious that it might lead to an increase in use of fair value rather than the reverse.

Wednesday, 11 November 2009

Fair Value and Accounting Politics

The title link is to an article in the FT about the European reaction to the IASB's proposals on fair value accounting. The IASB proposes to reform the unsatisfactory IAS39, which classifies financial instruments into somewhat arbitrary categories. There will be the option to value items with predictable cash flows on an amortised cost basis (like a tangible fixed asset) rather than marking to market (fair value). However the EU is worried this will disadvantage European banks in comparison with US ones that account under different rules.

The moral of this situation: financial reporting is strongly influenced by politics and competition whatever the theoretical arguments may be.

Thursday, 1 October 2009

Monitoring Board

In January 2009, the IASB formed a 'monitoring board' composed of representatives of international regulators. Said board has been fairly quiet but has just said that standards should be 'reliable, relevant, understandable and comparable'. This is an interesting straw in the wind because it reflects the old wording of the IASB conceptual framework, not the proposed new wording, which replaced 'reliable' with 'faithful representation'. Words matter and this was not just a cosmetic change. 'Faithful representation' was seen by some commentators as part of an ongoing trend to move towards fair values.

Wednesday, 30 September 2009

Another term, another financial crisis

The world seems to be a more stable place than it was a few months ago. The stock market has had a record run in the last quarter, house prices are stabilising, even the pound has stopped falling against the Euro.

Does this mean the financial crisis is over? I doubt it. The public finances are a mess and we can't see any fundamental change to them until after the election. What then? My guess is that whoever wins is going to squeeze public expenditure hard. Universities, inter alia, will be in for a thin time of it. However the size of the cuts needed to reduce borrowing to manageable levels is enormous. The alternative course of action - a rousing bout of inflation - is going to look awfully tempting to whoever wins the election. Index-linked bonds anyone?

Friday, 15 May 2009

The trouble with markets

Roger Martin argues (see title link) that linking managers rewards to share prices (eg with options) gives them an incentive to manage the 'expectations' market rather than the real market for production of goods and services. He fingers efficient markets theory, shareholder value and agency theory as the intellectual culprits and advocates reward based on 'real' performance.

He has a convincing case and a corollary of his argument would be a return to historical cost accounting rather than the use of fair values, which are based on the expectations market.